Originally Posted by
Pelicanidae
For what it's worth, my top 10 at this point (and brief descriptions for those not familiar) probably looks like:
1) Alexandre Sarr - 7'1 switchable centre with extremely good touch who projects as a shooter and rim protector, and who is a solid passer. Needs to gain muscle and develop the shot at 3pt range with consistency. Ridiculously mobile.
2) Nikola Topic - 6'5 PG with a near 7ft wingspan who, despite being super young for the class, just produces. Really good passer who maximises his height well in the PnR, strong finisher with craft, great speed in a straight line. Mediocre defender, can't shoot yet but projects alright.
3) Ron Holland II - 6'7 guard/wing who is a really strong athlete and plays with a fantastic motor. Good rebounder, can create for himself a little especially in the open court, and maximises that aggression and athleticism to be a very good defensive prospect. Poor handle and zero shooting right now - played PF at high school levels.
4) Rob Dillingham - 6'2 PG who is basically Kemba Walker if Kemba Walker was good on defense. Size limits his defense, but he has long arms and good hands and plays with effort. Great ball handler, willing passer, and has a highlight reel full of finishes at the rim. Quick release on a pullup jumper, projects well as a shooter for his size.
5) Zacherie Risacher - 6'8 wing who can shoot and has a super fast release with excellent relocation skills and fundamental mechanics. Can create off the bounce a little, though certainly not a primary. Good passer. Willing, switchable defender who works hard on that end and has good feet. Super young, too.
6) Isaiah Collier - 6'3. What if Zion was about 25% worse at everything and also 3 inches shorter, but had a pretty decent pullup jumper? That's Collier, basically. Strength based creation, gets into the paint at will, good passer and creator for others, you know the drill.
7) Stephon Castle - 6'6 guard who can defend up and down the positions, generates a ton of deflections through hustle and refusing to be screened out of plays, a skilled connective passer, and is a very capable finisher especially when he has the opportunity to go off both feet. Decisive.
8) Cody Williams - 6'8 wing with a 7'2 wingspan, with great pace and control of his handle. Crafty finisher, though lacking in burst. Moves well off ball, always cutting, and is a good offensive rebounder despite being currently slightly thin, and finishes excellently at the rim. Projects well as a c&s three point guy but has no real pullup game as of right now. Release could use some fine tuning. Quick hands, good defender.
9) Kel'el Ware - 7'0 centre with a slightly janky release but consistent success stretching the floor. Can create a little with the ball in his hands, though obviously not a primary creator. Good rim runner, and started playing like a big man last year by being willing to take contact. Solid defender against other bigs, wouldn't call him super switchy.
10) Reed Sheppard - 6'3 Kentucky guard with a 6'3 wingspan who can shoot the absolute leather off the ball and has great mechanics and fundamentals for shooting and relocating. Not an athlete of major burst or power, but has good hands to compensate a little on defense - still, size will be an issue for him. Smart player though who just doesn't really make mistakes, which helps limit the risks of having such a small guard on the court.
As you can tell, it's not a glowing review of the class. Rob Dillingham is good, for example, but most years I would not put a guy as small as him in the top 5 unless he was electric, but it's just that kind of draft class. Obviously in 5 years there will be some random second rounder who erupts that I didn't see coming and we'll all look back on that as a miss, but approaching the draft today, it's not a great one.
That's my top 10.
Next 5 guys is some combination of Matas Buzelis, Dalton Knecht, Ajay Mitchell, Tidjane Salaun, and Yves Missi. Maybe Donovan Clingan.