.
Pelicans Report
 

View Poll Results: Who do you want the Pelicans to trade for Scoot?

Voters
47. You may not vote on this poll
  • Trade BI

    8 17.02%
  • Trade Zion

    20 42.55%
  • Trade Either

    1 2.13%
  • Don't Trade Either of them

    18 38.30%
Page 5 of 8 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 LastLast
Results 101 to 125 of 183

Thread: BI or Zion: Who do you want the Pelicans to trade for Scoot?

  1. #101
    Basketball Guru
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    jacksonville,fl/new orleans
    Posts
    4,171
    Quote Originally Posted by As I See It View Post
    SURPRISE!!! SURPRISE!!!

    Now that the Max Contract is in the bank, his true colors can be displayed.

    ````

    Yeah, let's trade BI!!!
    zion is not in position to demand where he want to go...so zion camp will not run his trade like AD camp did us....

  2. #102
    Charter Member PELICANSFAN's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Kenner, LA
    Posts
    23,321
    Quote Originally Posted by hornetsrebirth View Post
    No actual source here but



    Its starting to seem real enough that now I am wondering what the trade would look like besides the pick.
    Not a source. Even someone like Jake Madison is laughing at it. That site posts fantasy trade ideas all day long (look at their timeline). Also, it is based out of NY.

  3. #103
    Quote Originally Posted by 6warddude View Post
    zion is not in position to demand where he want to go...so zion camp will not run his trade like AD camp did us....
    You are right, and for the time being, the Pels can still get something valuable back from trading Zion. Wait another season or two though, and then it will not be Zion running his trade, but every team that the Pels try trading him to. Know what I mean? Y'all might even have to give up assets to get him off the books then.
    Last edited by LAL1947; 06-14-2023 at 05:17 PM.

  4. #104
    Quote Originally Posted by LAL1947 View Post
    You are right, and for the time being, the Pels can still get something valuable back from trading Zion. Wait another season or two though, and then it will not be Zion running his trade, but every team that the Pels try trading him to. Know what I mean? Y'all might even have to give up assets to get him off the books then.
    In two seasons, Zion will still have 3 years left on his contract which makes it more valuable if he's playing at all.

    If he's not playing at all, there are provisions in Zion's contract that make it far cheaper than it seems - a lot of his money is unguaranteed and relates to games played. We don't know the exact details surrounding that - exactly how many games, exactly how much is unguaranteed - but it's something guys like Shamit have mentioned a lot in the past.

    He also has unguaranteed money relating to his weight over the course of the deal.

    Part of the reason Zion's contract is so good is that there are so many benefits in it for the team that holds it - he has basically none of the power. There's a ton of unguaranteed money, it's long term, and there are no options.
    Basketball.

  5. #105
    Quote Originally Posted by hornetsrebirth View Post
    It?s starting to seem real because rumors are coming from both sides, we have never seen that before
    You can't say that we're seeing rumours from both sides, because we have no idea where the rumours are coming from, because there's no source. That's what it means when there's no source.

    In this case, the rumours appear to be coming from a Knicks fan's imagination.

  6. #106
    Quote Originally Posted by Pelicanidae View Post
    You can't say that we're seeing rumours from both sides, because we have no idea where the rumours are coming from, because there's no source. That's what it means when there's no source.

    In this case, the rumours appear to be coming from a Knicks fan's imagination.
    Then surely # 1 will come out shortly and deny all this nonsense publicly, huh? I mean there is no reason to put New Orleans fans through this "bull"

  7. #107
    Snarky Optimistic Guy msusousaphone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Lake Charles
    Posts
    4,803
    Reading the tea leaves of snippets put out by the team over the past few years, I'd wager the FO is not looking to trade BI but would entertain an offer if the value were overwhelming (which Scoot isn't) but are on the fence about Zion so anything decent would be considered.

    All we know for sure is that the Pels like Scoot and want to get him. Every other talking point about BI and Zion has been pure speculation. At the end of the day, I bet we end up keeping BI and Zion and not getting Scoot. 2nd most likely is we trade Zion for a package including Scoot. I don't think BI is even being discussed.
    Last edited by msusousaphone; 06-14-2023 at 05:57 PM.
    BI, Zion, and CJ had a net rating of +3 when on the court together. BI and Zion had a +13.4, BI and CJ had a +13.2, Zion and CJ was just +5.4.

    BI and Zion worked. BI and CJ worked. It was CJ and Zion and all three together that didn't work.

  8. #108
    Quote Originally Posted by As I See It View Post
    Then surely # 1 will come out shortly and deny all this nonsense publicly, huh?
    Even players who do talk to the media never come out and publicly address rumours about them, let alone rumours with only 2000 likes posted by nobody Twitter accounts

    There is not a single player in the NBA that would ''come out'' to publicly address that tweet. Except maybe Kd, because he's got that itchy twitter finger.

  9. #109
    Snarky Optimistic Guy msusousaphone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Lake Charles
    Posts
    4,803
    A very likely scenario is that the Pels have no intentions of trading either Zion or BI for Scoot. They really could just be kicking the tires on a deal for a bunch of picks and some youth....which probably won't get the deal done but it's still a likely scenario.

    So then these Zion rumors come out and the Pels PR tells Zion "we're not going to trade you. Just ignore this stuff for a few weeks and it will go away after the draft". It makes more sense to everyone not to address it.

  10. #110
    Quote Originally Posted by msusousaphone View Post
    So then these Zion rumors come out and the Pels PR tells Zion "we're not going to trade you. Just ignore this stuff for a few weeks and it will go away after the draft". It makes more sense to everyone not to address it.
    That's the case for every player, not just Zion.

    Anyone actually think that if that exact same tweet was made about BI, he'd suddenly be issuing statements? Not a chance. Players usually don't even respond to rumours by Woj and Shams, it would be absurd to expect a response for a semi-successful tweet from a nobody twitter account. Like, legitimately worrying for you to expect that. No connection to reality kind of thing.

    I'm not saying you do, I'm just talking generally.

  11. #111
    Starter
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    191
    Is it possible to construct a 3 team trade where Zion goes to New York, JV goes to Charlotte with Dyson, and Mitchell Robinson comes to New Orleans. We throw in some draft picks and also get #2 to draft Scoot?

  12. #112
    Starter
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    191
    I found a trade that works using Spotrac:

    Pels receive:

    Mitchell Robinson
    Gordon Hayward

    Knicks receive:

    Zion

    Bobcats receive:

    JV
    Evan Fournier

    Of course, there needs to be draft picks involved but you can't do that on Spotrac.

  13. #113
    Pistol Pete Would Be Proud!! donato's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Posts
    2,686
    Quote Originally Posted by HorneyTexan View Post
    I found a trade that works using Spotrac:

    Pels receive:

    Mitchell Robinson
    Gordon Hayward

    Knicks receive:

    Zion

    Bobcats receive:

    JV
    Evan Fournier

    Of course, there needs to be draft picks involved but you can't do that on Spotrac.
    Use Fanspo.com It's much better for trades.

  14. #114
    My question would be (at least my first major question), why would Charlotte do that?

    They'd essentially be trading Scoot for JV, which is not a move that makes any sense for them.

  15. #115
    So, talked to a buddy who is a sports writer based in NYC who covers mainly college basketball but is pretty plugged in with the pros as well, especially on the business/management side. His take was that most of the trade chatter was not coming from the Pels at all, but from Charlotte which is trying to bid up offers from several teams for the #2 pick. But he also said a prominent agent told him Charlotte is legitimately interested in a deal for Zion, partly for basketball reasons, partly for team valuation reasons and partly for Nike marketing reasons. Wasn’t sure if serious talks had happened but had heard Michael Jordan was still a believer in Zion’s potential to be an MVP-level player. Take it fwiw…

  16. #116
    Snarky Optimistic Guy msusousaphone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Lake Charles
    Posts
    4,803
    What I'm telling my kids you said:
    Quote Originally Posted by new city champ View Post
    So, talked to a buddy
    and IT'S HAPPENING

  17. #117
    Quote Originally Posted by new city champ View Post
    So, talked to a buddy who is a sports writer based in NYC who covers mainly college basketball but is pretty plugged in with the pros as well, especially on the business/management side. His take was that most of the trade chatter was not coming from the Pels at all, but from Charlotte which is trying to bid up offers from several teams for the #2 pick. But he also said a prominent agent told him Charlotte is legitimately interested in a deal for Zion, partly for basketball reasons, partly for team valuation reasons and partly for Nike marketing reasons. Wasn’t sure if serious talks had happened but had heard Michael Jordan was still a believer in Zion’s potential to be an MVP-level player. Take it fwiw…
    MJ probably think if Charlotte has Zion that he can drive up the asking price on the Hornets

  18. #118
    Quote Originally Posted by rebelman View Post
    MJ probably think if Charlotte has Zion that he can drive up the asking price on the Hornets
    There are legitimate reasons to think Charlotte might be interested in both Zion and BI.

    Zion has the MJ/Nike connection, and he's from there, and it might drive up the team value if he's looking to sell.

    Ingram was drafted by Kupchak, who is the Hornets GM right now, and who has never stopped praising him whenever asked - and he's also from there, and pairing him with LaMelo would probably make the playoffs in the East, which would also drive up team value potentially.

    There are connections for both players, in that sense. It's actually slightly funny, I've seen a bunch of people on Twitter saying that it makes sense to send Zion there because he's from NC, while completely ignoring that Ingram is also from NC

  19. #119
    Quote Originally Posted by Pelicanidae View Post
    There are legitimate reasons to think Charlotte might be interested in both Zion and BI.

    Zion has the MJ/Nike connection, and he's from there, and it might drive up the team value if he's looking to sell.

    Ingram was drafted by Kupchak, who is the Hornets GM right now, and who has never stopped praising him whenever asked - and he's also from there, and pairing him with LaMelo would probably make the playoffs in the East, which would also drive up team value potentially.

    There are connections for both players, in that sense. It's actually slightly funny, I've seen a bunch of people on Twitter saying that it makes sense to send Zion there because he's from NC, while completely ignoring that Ingram is also from NC
    Zion is from South Carolina

  20. #120
    Quote Originally Posted by rebelman View Post
    Zion is from South Carolina
    He was born in Salisbury NC. I know he went to middle school at Marion but idk how much time was spent in NC before the SC began.

  21. #121


    MJ no longer Hornets owner, the ''MJ connection'' with Zion severed.

  22. #122
    So all this much to do about nothing, kinda like being a Pels fan.

  23. #123
    Quote Originally Posted by HorneyTexan View Post
    Bobcats receive:
    What year is it

  24. #124
    Quote Originally Posted by luckyman View Post
    But BI is still only 25 and still hasn't reached his own peak yet. He is definitely a #1 option on a contender.
    In which world? Put him on the Nuggets, the Lakers, the Suns, the Warriors, the Bucks, the Celtics, the Heat, the Sixers. That's half the teams that made the playoffs this year. He would be the #1 option on NONE of them.

  25. #125
    Quote Originally Posted by RobertM320 View Post
    In which world? Put him on the Nuggets, the Lakers, the Suns, the Warriors, the Bucks, the Celtics, the Heat, the Sixers. That's half the teams that made the playoffs this year. He would be the #1 option on NONE of them.
    That's a misleading and very illogical way to go about it. In a merry go round, which of those team's #1 option would remain so on a different contender??

    Is Jayson Taysom a #1 option on the Nuggets, Bucks, Warriors, Sixers, or Lakers? He'd remain so only on the Heat. But you'd have some folk who'd still prefer Jimmy Butler (not me).

    Is Jimmy Butler the #1 option on any of those teams outside of maybe the Celtics? And his team that actually made the finals.

    Is Steph the #1 option for the Nuggets, Lakers, Bucks, or 76ers?

    Also BI has been in the worst situation of anybody on that list. So that really throws off the comps.

    He's the one that's on a team still trying to build through the draft and has had his sidekick not play At ALL the last 2 years. How did that work out for Lebron?

    When that was the case for Denver, even with a still better roster, how far did Jokic get?
    Last edited by luckyman; 06-17-2023 at 05:26 PM.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •