Should be way more than whats being discussed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wanted to start a thread to get everyone's opinions on the issue and suggestions on what the penalty should be to try to keep teams from going over the cap.
Would be nice to get as many posts from GM's as possible so CP3 has something to go off of if he decides to implement a tax penalty.
Should be way more than whats being discussed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I dont think it should be related to points at all...I know that's our only currency so I don't have a suggestion yet, but maybe after a certain threshold is met the team loses their bird rights...I mean it's hard to trade or sign free agents when over the cap so there is that
HR Sim League Boston Celtics - 2002 World Champions
PG: Sam Cassell, Steve Blake
SG: Grant Hill, Michael Dickerson
SF: Josh Childress, Jamie Feick
PF: Chris Webber, Jamie Feick, Jason Maxiell
C: Shaquille O'Neal, John Amaechi
Unfortunately, some teams just can't help it, as their players were drafted with awful contracts already attached. Some of them will expire at the end of this season, but there are still a few out there. Also, we're dealing with a simulated free agency here, which means that a team could quite likely end up with cap-eating contracts by accident. A team with cap space could end up over the cap in one sim, stuck with a player he now has no need for, and will have to pay for a mistake not fully his own. Has that been properly considered?
HR Sim League
If you want to field a good veteran team you'll be a good ways over the cap in a few years.
made by sportzin.com
Picks and players won't be taken away, that's not a good plan. And you're wrong about "knowing how much a player makes" Damon Stoudamire hasn't been all nba or an all star and is making 12+ million. No one would have thought he would be making that and I'm sure there are other guys on bad contracts that aren't all stars
HR SIM LEAGUE: MEMPHIS GRIZZLIES
Mod over at reddit.com/r/NOLAPelicans
Why should their be a penalty? We don't have any influences from bigger or smaller markets. Everything is even. Why penalize those with good teams? Any good team is going to be a bit over the cap right now.
Terrell Brandon | Vince Carter | Keith Van Horn| Theo Ratliff | Zydrunas Ilgauskas
2003-2004 | 46-36 | 4th in the Pacific Division |5th in the Western Conference
I just don't like the idea of punishing people for actions they made while there was no rule against it.
If we were to do anything, which I doubt we will, it would be something like teams 20M over the cap can't claim player points, they can only claim team points, or something like that.
Also, any argument made that draft position (the original draft) affected things and really hurt some is invalid. BeeBall Reasons had the last pick in the draft and is now a contender.
Everything is even.
The salary cap is also ridiculously low considering the contracts being given currently, so I don't see the point in a luxury tax.
A hard cap on the other hand might not be a bad idea. Say, $80 million? The Spurs, by the far highest paid team in the league, are at $74 million. Still, it could prevent some teams to constantly sign MLE guys every single year. It just wouldn't be all that realistic.
The fact that someone is over the cap and no there wouldnt be any consequences if they go even more over, to the point when they are throwing contracts at anyone because they know there aren't any penalties is what concerns me.
I don't like the idea of penalizing either.
Emeka Okafor - Al Jefferson - Carmelo Anthony - Manu Ginobili - Damon Stoudamire
Brad Miller - Samaki Walker - Mickael Pietrus - Aaron McKie - Shaun Livingston
The Footbawl Blog: Men who care (and cry) entirely too much about football
PR Sim League: Miami Heat
TJ Ford - Jason Terry - James Posey - Stromile Swift - Andrew Bynum
Bench: Juan Carlos Navarro - Cedric Ceballos - Trevor Ariza - Marc Jackson - Darko Milicic
Still, nobody knew salaries, no matter what their position was in a draft, top 10 pick doesn't just guarantee you salary. I just thought that you were being ridiculous for calling for people's points, picks, and players. Thats a little much considering we were going in blind to cap hits and just plain stupid. The only thing you lose for being over is money in the NBA, and our form of money is Points. So that would be the only thing that would make sense to 'tax'.
In the real NBA, you have two choices: Stay under the cap or compete. You can't do both for a good length of time. Look at the hole OKC's in with Harden. And there are penalties for going over the cap. Look at the Lakers, the team I think is the reasoning behind the "tax 'em hard!" argument. They may look good now, but a lot of their players are overachieving, and with Shaq & Hill's bloated contracts, they'll have to fill their team with cheap bums and rookies for years to come. This is likely their last year as a serious contender, barring an extremely fruitful (and highly unlikely) offseason. Why do you think I traded Zo? I made that deal, along with trading Penny, to free up cap space for the future. It looks like a smart move now, thanks to Antawn's emergence, but I'm sure most of y'all were snickering at me after those deals, figuring it was a blatant attempt to tank. And guess what? As of now, I'm still over the cap, and will likely have to go over it next season if I want to continue to make strides as a contender. That's just how it is.
Last edited by Xist2inspire; 08-28-2012 at 06:17 PM.
Well **** it, I'll go around slinging contracts at any and every player!!! Calm down first of all, and I just was trying to help or make the league more funner and equal. Anyways IDC anymore, just was throwing out my opinion.
I like the idea of being $20-25+ you cant claim points... that's kinda cool.
But honestly, if a team is over salary cap, then the only players they can THROW money at are their own... otherwise they can only offer MLE LLE or vet min to players.
Hornets Report Sim League presents...
2005-06 Season Record: 46-28
Starting 5: C Tyson Chandler | PF Brian Grant | SF Corliss Williamson | SG Mike Miller | PG Gilbert Arenas
Key Reserves: Scot Pollard | Channing Frye | James Thomas | John Salmons | Tony Allen | Milt Palacio
Hard cap at like 75-80mil would be nice
Sorry if I pissed anyone off from throwing out a OPINION!!!!!!!
I also think a strict penalty for being over makes trades more difficult and people will have to really think about if they want to trade for a $20 mill dollar player. The timing would have to be right if they think they can contend for a championship. I think overall a tax penalty lessens the gap between the mediocre/bad teams with the elite teams and it makes it harder to build a contending team.
Those are just my opinions and I could be way off base. At least we are discussing it tho.
Last edited by PrepP; 08-28-2012 at 06:34 PM.
and how did they acquire that talent?
They did a good drop drafting talented players? They traded for those players?
I said before we even drafted that people need to be careful with their moves because "superteams" will be formed. Not to call anyone out, but there have been a number of trades already in two seasons that were extremely lopsided and helped other teams really improve.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)